TGT · Earnings quality
Target’s adjusted earnings still include a refund
Adjusted earnings don’t automatically remove every unusual benefit. Read the definition before forecasting the profit again.

When you see “adjusted earnings,” it’s tempting to hear “the profit this business can keep making.” That isn’t what the label promises. It means someone chose a set of items to remove. You still need to read the list.
Target offers a useful example. Its November 18 release reports third-quarter earnings per share of $2.65 under both standard accounting rules (GAAP) and its adjusted measure. Both include a $0.50 tariff-refund benefit.
The refund is real money. The question for a shareholder is whether to put the same benefit into next year’s earnings forecast.
Two adjustments, two different comparisons
| Comparison | Q3 2025 | Q3 2026 | Growth |
|---|---|---|---|
| GAAP EPS | $1.51 | $2.65 | 75% |
| Company-adjusted EPS | $1.78 | $2.65 | 49% |
| Adjusted EPS less 2026 refund benefit | $1.78 | $2.15 | 21% |
The last row subtracts $0.50 from $2.65, then compares the result with last year’s adjusted $1.78. It isn’t Target’s published Adjusted EPS. The prior-year adjustment removed business-transformation costs; this year’s adjusted figure retains the refund.
Even after that subtraction, earnings grew. “A benefit helped” and “the business improved” can both be true. Removing a favorable item shouldn’t become an excuse to ignore the remaining improvement. Nor does this single subtraction produce a complete estimate of recurring profit.
“Adjusted” isn’t a shared recipe
Compare Gap’s release the following day. Gap reported quarterly diluted EPS of $0.86 and adjusted EPS of $0.82. Its adjusted measure removes tariff recoveries and related interest income. Target’s measure leaves its refund benefit in.
That doesn’t make either label a lie. It means the labels answer different questions. Copying two adjusted earnings figures into the same spreadsheet doesn’t make their definitions match.
A fair comparison starts with the underlying entries. What happened? Where did the amount enter earnings? Does the company remove it? Would you expect it again? An investor can disagree with management’s choice without claiming the accounting is wrong.
Theory A · Earnings chart
Read the earnings definition before pricing the forecast
Start with 5Y, then switch to 2Y to inspect the recent annual periods. The chart compares market value with earnings per share multiplied by today’s share count and a reference price-to-earnings ratio (P/E). Dashed values are analyst estimates, not promises. It does not remove tariff refunds or reproduce the quarterly table above.
Includes reported history and analyst forecasts. Open Analyze to change the P/E or other valuation multiple.
The reference multiple is a historical average, not a fair-value estimate. If that average is not positive and finite, the chart uses unscaled earnings instead. Negative historical earnings are hidden. Open Analyze to change the multiple; don’t assume the chart’s data provider uses either retailer’s adjusted definition.
Keep the refund. Don’t automatically repeat it.
Imagine a business earns $10 per share from its ongoing activities and receives a separate $2-per-share cash benefit. This is a hypothetical example, not a Target forecast. At a chosen P/E of 20, treating all $12 as repeatable produces a $240 valuation. Applying that multiple only to the $10 produces $200 before considering the separate benefit.
The benefit still belongs somewhere in the analysis. Cash retained by the business can increase its value, but receiving $2 once is not the same as earning another $2 every year. Check what happened to the cash and avoid counting it again if your balance-sheet valuation already includes it. Neither illustrative price is a recommendation.
Before accepting an earnings forecast, write down which unusual benefits it includes and why they should recur. If the forecast already excludes a refund, don’t subtract it twice. If future refunds are uncertain, keep that possibility separate from the profits you expect ordinary operations to produce.
For a different way accounting can change the earnings headline, see Uber’s income-tax effects. Then test the price you’re paying with a simple earnings-and-multiple example.
Sources & assumptions
Tables label the periods covered by each reported figure. The worked examples use made-up assumptions to explain the math; they are not live prices or forecasts.
- Target third-quarter 2026 earnings release
November 18, 2026. Quarterly results, tariff-refund benefits and EPS reconciliation.
- Gap third-quarter fiscal 2026 earnings release
November 19, 2026. Reported and adjusted earnings definitions.
Calculations and interpretation: Theory A. This article is investment research for educational use, not a personalized recommendation.













